Xi'an police reported on November 17 that a 29-year-old woman had been placed in criminal detention on suspicion of fraud: since 2023, they say, she had placed more than 400 “refund-only” orders at Hema stores citing reasons like “tastes bad” and “not fresh,” never sent a single item back, and cost merchants more than 17,000 yuan (≈US$2,400, approximate) [1]. The police notice states that the amount reached the criminal-filing standard, that her behavior is suspected of fraud, and that the case remains under further investigation [2]. For cross-border shoppers, the rule this case clarifies is simple: refund without return is a conditional courtesy, not a statutory right. The practical move is to claim by the conditions, keep your own evidence, and assume a cross-border order will require an actual return, if a return option exists at all.

Xi'an police drew the line in their public reminder: refund-only is a merchant-set after-sale rule “with explicit applicable conditions,” and it is “not a back door for taking goods for free” [1]. When your claim is honest, the mechanism still works for you; what escalated her routine into a criminal case was the invented reasoning, repeated across more than 400 orders [1].

The 7-day return is law; refund-only is a courtesy

For returns, the statutory protection is the seven-day no-reason return: within seven days of receipt, you may return goods for no reason and get your money back [3]. Refund-only is not part of that law. CCTV's November investigation describes it as “not a statutory right, but an after-sales arrangement platforms formed in competition with each other” [3].

A Chengdu court's Q&A on refund-only disputes explains what the courtesy actually is: a platform-granted “convenience termination right” and “breach remedy,” whose premise is that the merchant really did breach — shipping the wrong item, or goods with serious quality problems, or nothing at all [4]. If your goods genuinely arrive defective, or the seller fails to ship and stops responding, the court's answer is to use the platform's refund-only and similar after-sale rules without hesitation: “the law and the platform will protect your legitimate rights” [4]. What the court calls abuse is the mirror image — claiming “goods not as described” or “quality defects” for items received in perfect condition, sometimes with photos of mold downloaded from the internet as fake proof. That, the court says, violates the good-faith principle underlying all civil dealings [4].

Tmall's own customer service told CCTV that its current refund rules mainly cover limited scenarios — goods never received, or shops judged to be selling counterfeits — and that big-ticket items rarely qualify for refund-only at all [3]. Liability escalates: a buyer who keeps goods and money without cause faces a civil claim to return them or pay; fabricated-claim refunds of smaller amounts can bring administrative fines or short detention; repeated claims whose cumulative amount reaches the “relatively large” threshold for fraud can bring prison time [4].

Courts are already enforcing the line

The consequences are not theoretical — one final conviction and one civil judgment show both ends of the escalations. In Hunan's Hengshan County, a defendant surnamed Tan carried out more than 100 refund-only incidents from October 2025 to January 2026, ordering high-end durians and cherries on Taobao and Douyin, using AI image generation to fake rot and mold on the fruit, claiming refund-only with the photos as proof, and reselling the intact fruit at a discount on Xianyu and WeChat Moments; the goods were appraised at more than 16,000 yuan (≈US$2,300, approximate) [5]. Taobao's data monitoring flagged that multiple refund-only orders shared one delivery address; after the county procuratorate prosecuted him, the court sentenced him to one year in prison and a 5,000-yuan (≈US$700, approximate) fine for fraud — a judgment rendered April 29, 2026, now final with no appeal [5].

At the civil end, the Beijing Internet Court heard a buyer who ordered bedding sets across multiple accounts, then reused one genuine return tracking number across two platforms — Taobao refunded one order, the same number was filled into his Xiaohongshu returns — so that all 11 orders were refunded while one returned item showed visible use. The court found a 100% refund rate, an exploit of platforms' information gaps, and ordered the buyer to pay over 8,000 yuan (≈US$1,130, approximate) in economic loss, courier and attorney fees, grounding the ruling in Article 132 of the Civil Code: no abuse of civil rights [3]. The judges also warned that severe abuse of return rights can reach criminal law, and courts in Shanghai, Guangdong and Zhejiang have heard similar cases [3].

Why did such claims pass in the first place? The evidence requirements are not symmetrical. CCTV reviewed merchant back-ends: merchants appealing a refund must supply complete, clear unboxing video, close-ups of tracking numbers, and visible proof of where the goods were damaged, while a buyer initiating a claim typically ticks a reason and enters a tracking number [3]. The same asymmetry explains the big-ticket cases: in one, a Shanghai buyer ordered two four-door commercial freezers for 4,070 yuan (≈US$570, approximate) in May, the platform advanced the full refund under its after-sale rules in August, and the merchant — who found the freezers still running in the buyer's store — had not recovered them as of the report [3].

Since February 1, platforms can't force merchants to absorb refund-only

The friction is now moving to claim-level review, because the ground rules changed. China's market regulator and the national cyberspace administration have jointly issued the Measures for Supervising and Administering Network Trading Platform Rules, targeting platform rules that were “opaque and unfair” — a move CCTV reported on January 13 [6]. CCTV quotes its Article 27: platform operators may not use platform rules to force or covertly force merchants to bear refund-without-return liability that harms their lawful interests [3]. The Measures took effect February 1, 2026 [3].

In written replies to CCTV, six platforms describe the shift in their own words: JD says its refund-without-return function no longer exists and merchants choose between a refund and a return; Pinduoduo cites a 36-hour handling window for merchants and says it dropped the rigid rule of automatic refunds after timeout; Taobao-Tmall says refund requests are first negotiated between merchant and buyer, with the platform stepping in only when necessary; Xiaohongshu says it has never run a forced refund-only rule and handles after-sale disputes through a negotiation mechanism; Douyin points to its rules for non-normal consumers and says its risk-control models identify professional claimants and batch-abuse accounts and intercept baseless full-refund demands; Kuaishou says it has no rule or policy forcing merchants into refund-only and uses AI models to identify malicious buyers [3]. These are the platforms' self-descriptions, not an independent audit — but they all point the same direction: fewer automatic passes. Consumer-law researcher Chen Yinjiang's check on the new rules is blunt: high-frequency refund-only claims, evidence-fabrication claims, and disputed orders must move to human substantive review, “not simply auto-refund and be done with it” [3].

For you, this means claims get closer scrutiny than before. A documented claim stands a far better chance of surviving that check; an invented one is what the models are built to catch. The first consequence is account-level, and it already appeared in the Xi'an case: after repeated violations, the woman could no longer place orders in the app, so she moved on to Hema storefronts on other e-commerce platforms [1].

The cross-border playbook

On cross-border orders, both halves of the rule matter at once: the statutory 7-day return applies in principle, and in practice the seller's own policy usually decides. The Hangzhou Internet Court's 2024 guidelines for cross-border e-commerce say that consumers and operators in cross-border retail import are consumers and operators under the Consumer Protection Law, so “in principle, the seven-day no-reason return applies” [7]. Guangdong's consumer council describes the practice on the ground (2024 guidance): because cross-border retail imports are declared in the buyer's own name and cannot be resold domestically after entry, the 7-day no-reason return and treble-damages provisions are “difficult to apply in practice,” and most cross-border sellers and platforms offer no return service at all [8]. Read together, the two authorities give you the same instruction: never assume, always open the seller's policy before you pay.

One customs change shows how the return-cost problem is being tackled — on the shipping side, not yours. From April 1, 2026, customs generalizes cross-district returns for cross-border retail export parcels (code 9610), letting enterprises send returned goods back through any customs port instead of the original exit one; the policy targets the industry pain of returns that are “hard, costly and slow” [9]. It is an enterprise-side reverse-logistics fix, not a consumer right to return — your actual options still come from the seller.

What to actually do, in order:

  1. Before paying: read the platform and seller rules on returns, taxes, delivery and after-sale terms, and watch for notices that an item is excluded from 7-day no-reason return; the Guangdong council's checklist also says to read and confirm the cross-border transaction risk notice before ordering [8]. Sellers that exclude goods from returns are supposed to mark that clearly and add a separate, prominent confirmation step — if you never saw one, that matters to your position later [7].
  2. On arrival: check the goods against the order. For a genuine defect, or a seller who shipped the wrong item, never shipped, or stopped responding, the court's guidance is to use the platform's refund-only and similar after-sale rules confidently — legitimate use is protected [4].
  3. Document as you go: keep the unboxing video, photos of any damage, and your chat log. Merchant appeals depend on complete evidence while buyer claims start lighter, so the buyer who documents holds the stronger position when a dispute lands on a reviewer's desk [3].
  4. Dispute through official channels: for sellers registered in Hong Kong or Macao, the Greater Bay Area complaint-transfer platform (ts.gdcc315.cn) routes complaints to the consumer councils there; otherwise use the national 12315 platform, the consumers' association Smart 3·15 platform, or your local 12345 hotline [8].
  5. Claim with the truth: the same records that support a real claim expose a fake one. In the Hunan case, a deliberate resale scheme built on AI-faked “rotten fruit” photos and invented reasons ended in a one-year fraud sentence [4] [5].

This playbook is China's framework. On other markets the specific rules differ; what travels is the method — policy before payment, documentation on arrival, escalation through official channels.

Bottom line

The Xi'an case shows where the refund-only boundary now sits: the 7-day no-reason return is your statutory baseline, refund-without-return is a courtesy with conditions, platforms can no longer push its cost onto merchants by default, and courts have shown what fabricated claims cost. According to police, the detained woman's case remains under investigation [2]. For your own orders, every check that matters is in your hands today: the seller's return policy and risk notice before you pay, your unboxing evidence on arrival, and the official complaint channels when something goes wrong.